No to separate events. It's not about them, it's about your LO. If they don't want to go then it's on them
The baby is 1. He won't know or care.
No to separate parties. One party for everyone, they either attend or they don’t. Regardless of being parents/in-laws, divorced or still together, normal adults are able to put aside petty squabbles for important occasions.
Absolutely not I would be telling them they can visit if they please but that you will not be having a separate celebration just for them because they’ve deemed the cabin is more important than little ones birthday when they simply could leave for it later or return early to be able to do both.
I wouldnt do seperate - if someone cant make it due to other commitments then its not on you to plan additional events. Same as anyone elses birthday
I do mini vacation/travel trips for bday… I rather spend the money going somewhere then having/throwing a party make memories and babe gets to experience the world
I’ve dealt with similar situations and not having a good relationship with my mother in law makes these situations feel impossible to get right. I would say over the last year or so I’ve started standing up for myself and my family. If you can’t make it to the event I’m planning for ny baby’s birthday and you want to be able to see them and celebrate then YOU can come to see them. I’m not making a whole separate event just for you. Sorry it’s not about you. It’s about the baby and if you can’t make the date I picked work then that’s not my problem. My baby is either more of a priority to you or you can see them when it works for you. But I’m done catering my life to other people. All I’m focusing on is my little one, my relationship with my partner and myself. Everything else isn’t as important.
Sounds like your sibling in law is regularly a problem. Regardless, I wouldn’t be doing separate events. You put the time and effort into the main event, and their reason for not coming isn’t good enough to warrant a whole separate event that I’m sure they’d still want you to plan/fund. So like one of my favorite TikTok creators say…”No, we won’t be doing that “
I would absolutely not be having one for each side of the family. If someone can't or doesn't want to attend then fine, but that's on them. When the kids are older then I'd potentially have a family party as well as one with kid's friends but personally I wouldn't do that every year
Sounds like a huge them problem. You are under no obligation to appease others!
They're choosing to miss the event. Yes they can come for dinner another time if they want to give their present in person. But it's not a second birthday event
I personally wouldn't do a separate event. Maybe if they wanna see your baby on another day/time they can just stop by your house? I hate doing multiple events too lol