@JL those are great ideas! I could probably get some bigger eggs...
Mini ducks and stickers are the non candy ones my LO got last year
Chocolate is safe, so like mini kitkats or reeses (just not foil, ask me how I know lol).
Stickers
Temporary tattoos
Fruit snacks!
Those bendy stretch tubes or rubber duckies if you can find smallish ones? Mini pouches like those small applesauce ones?